GroupFlow vs Join It: Membership Tool or Club Platform?

Join It is membership management software: a member database, dues and recurring payments, renewal reminders, digital membership cards and event registration. It is designed to work alongside the website and tools your organization already has, rather than replace them.

GroupFlow is built for clubs that meet in person, and it includes the parts of a club Join It leaves to other tools: your website, member chat and discussion forums. Here is how the two compare. For other comparisons, see all GroupFlow alternatives.

Overview

Category Join It GroupFlow
Built for Associations, nonprofits and clubs adding membership to their tools In-person, member-based clubs
Pricing model Plan and member capacity, from $29 a month Tiered plans
Fee on payments 1.5% to 3.0% service fee, plus Stripe's processing fee Processing fee only (2.5% + $0.29), no platform fee
Website A membership profile page, or widgets on your existing site A full website, edited visually on the page itself
Member to member Messages through the directory, if an admin turns them on Direct and group chat, and a discussion on every event, where hosts reach attendees themselves
Mobile Apple Wallet and Google Wallet cards; no app to install A members' app for iOS and Android

Membership & Payments

Both platforms handle membership types, renewals and reminders, and let members renew and update their own details.

Join It prices by plan and by the number of members you manage. Its plans start at $29 a month (Starter), $99 a month (Total) and $199 a month (Extra), and the price rises as you move to a higher member capacity. Annual billing takes 10% off, and nonprofits get a further 10%.

On top of the subscription, Join It charges a service fee on paid memberships and paid event registrations: 3.0% on Starter, 2.0% on Total and 1.5% on Extra. Stripe's own processing fee is charged separately. Free memberships and free registrations carry no service fee.

Some features need a higher plan. The member directory, digital membership cards, check-in and the embeddable purchase widget start on Total; custom domains, removing Join It's branding and a dedicated account manager are on Extra.

GroupFlow passes through its payment processor's fee, currently 2.5% of the transaction plus $0.29, and adds no application or platform fee on top. A club that collects $10,000 in dues a year pays Join It's Starter plan $300 in service fees before Stripe's charge; in GroupFlow that $300 stays with the club. Admins issue refunds themselves, in full or in part.

Events & Registration

Join It takes free and paid event registrations, with several ticket types per event and member pricing applied automatically by membership type and status. Staff check members in by scanning the QR code on their digital card, on the Total plan and above. A club that prefers Eventbrite can connect it instead.

GroupFlow's events include:

  • Public, member-only and invite-only events, with free and paid tickets.
  • Waitlists, one for the event or one for each ticket option.
  • Ticket transfers between members.
  • Time-slot tickets, for workshops, demos or office hours.
  • Repeating events. Set an event to repeat weekly, monthly or on a custom schedule. Each date is its own event, with its own registrations, waitlist, payments and check-in, and a change can apply to one date, the dates after it, or all upcoming dates.
  • Member-run events. Any active member can draft an event, unless your group turns that off. The member who drafts it can add co-hosts and volunteers, who check people in, move people off the waitlist and message attendees, without any access to the Admin Dashboard. Admins decide what gets published.

Communication & Community

In GroupFlow, members reach each other directly, without an administrator in between. A member messages another member or chats in a group conversation, and every event has its own discussion, where the host and the people coming talk before and after it. A volunteer who hosts an event reaches its attendees themselves, in that discussion or with an announcement to the event's attendees, without asking an administrator to send an email for them.

Join It sends email blasts to all your members or to a segment, and automated emails at points in a membership's life, such as a renewal reminder. Its member portal shows members their status, upcoming events and your organization's posts. Members can message each other through the directory, if an admin turns that on. For newsletters, Join It syncs with Mailchimp and Constant Contact.

Join It says itself that it may not be the best choice for an organization primarily looking for a platform to replace its entire public website, blog or community forum.

That is the part GroupFlow is built around. Besides chat and event discussions, it includes announcements to the whole club or to a segment of it and discussion forums, all inside your club's private space.

Your Website

Join It gives your organization a public profile page with your logo, a header image and your membership options. To add membership to the site you already have, such as WordPress, Squarespace or Wix, you link to Join It or embed its widget; the widget needs the Total plan.

GroupFlow includes your group's website, with public pages for visitors and members-only pages, a join page with dues, event listings, photos and videos, and an optional custom domain. You edit it on the page itself, in a visual editor, with no coding.

Mobile

Join It does not ask members to install an app. Its digital membership cards, on the Total plan and above, go into Apple Wallet or Google Wallet and update when a membership changes, and its member portal works in a mobile browser.

GroupFlow has a members' mobile app for iOS and Android, where members register for events and use the club's community features: the member directory, chat, forums and event discussions.

Pricing

What you pay for Join It GroupFlow
Subscription From $29, $99 or $199 a month, rising with member capacity A tiered plan
Fee on each payment 1.5% to 3.0% service fee, plus Stripe's processing fee 2.5% + $0.29, no platform fee
Member directory Total plan and above Included
Website Profile page, or widgets on a site you host elsewhere Included

Switching from Join It

Export your members from Join It to a spreadsheet, then import the CSV into GroupFlow. You see a preview before anything is saved, and can download any rows that failed to import so you can fix and re-import them. The CSV import covers names, email addresses and phone numbers, up to 500 members at a time. For membership dates, dues and profile fields, GroupFlow Support can do the import for you.

Which Platform Is Right for You?

Join It is a good fit for an organization that already has a website and other tools it is happy with, and wants a simple way to collect dues, issue membership cards and keep a member list.

If your club is a community that meets in person, GroupFlow gives you membership, events, payments, communication and your website in one place, with no service fee on the dues and tickets your members pay.